Calcium Challenges
Factors that fight calcium absorption
by Michelle Gibeault Traub, R.D.
As you
learned in last month’s " Get More from Your Calcium Supplement", some nutrients and conditions help with calcium
absorption. You’ve been using what you learned to properly balance your calcium
and vitamin D intake everyday, right? If so, congratulations, you are well on
your way to strong bones. But, be warned, there are challenges lurking. Some
nutrients can actually interfere with calcium absorption, or even strip it from
the bones. Let’s review some of the worst offenders.
Calcium’s Enemies
- Iron – Although iron is essential for maintaining
healthy red blood cells it competes for absorption with calcium. This means
that foods or supplements containing iron should be taken separately from calcium
supplements or calcium-rich foods. This is one reason why a standard
multi-vitamin really can’t meet your calcium needs. Most also contain iron
which means absorption of the mineral will potentially be inhibited.
- Soda containing phosphoric acid – Phosphorus in excess can upset the
balance of calcium ultimately causing it to be released from the bones. Regular
soda-drinkers (especially colas) have been found to have lower bone density
(see also, “Drink to Your Health”)
- Sodium –Our food supply is overflowing with
sodium. Other than promoting high blood pressure in salt-sensitive individuals,
the mineral has not been considered a major concern. However, experts are now
questioning sodium’s impact on overall health. Osteoporosis is one of their
primary concerns since excess sodium tends to pull calcium from the bones. Limiting
sodium intake to 2400 mg per day and being diligent about calcium intake can
help remedy the situation.
-
Protein – High protein diets tend to
upset the calcium balance in the body. As a result, foods like cottage cheese
and cheese, which contain calcium, are not considered to be ideal sources of
the mineral because of their high protein and sodium content.
-
Tobacco, Alcohol & Caffeine – They can be considered the toxic
trio in terms of bone health. Smoking, drinking alcohol, or consuming excess
caffeine all strip calcium from the bones.
-
Phytate – A compound found in wheat bran
and legumes such as pinto beans and peas, phytate can inhibit the absorption of
calcium. Since phytate is found in very healthy foods, these foods should not
be avoided, but rather calcium-rich foods or supplements should simply be taken
separately from high phytate foods whenever possible.
-
Oxalic acid (found in spinach,
rhubarb, and chocolate) – While phytate can impair absorption of the calcium in foods eaten with
it, oxalic acid only impacts the calcium in foods that contain it. For example,
Adora Calcium is made with premium chocolate which naturally contains oxalic
acid. Some of the calcium in this supplement is actually bound to that oxalic
acid. As a result, the makers of Adora add additional calcium to insure that
the product delivers a full 500 mg of elemental calcium per piece. In the case
of spinach, it is a bit trickier to estimate how much oxalic acid is actually
present. Therefore, even though spinach is considered to be fairly high in
calcium (272 mg per cup), it is not really recommended as one of the more
absorbable sources of the mineral.
-
Tannins – Tannins are acidic compounds
primarily found in tea that can also bind to calcium. Their impact seems to be
minimal, but adding a splash of milk to your tea will help offset their effects.
-
Sweat – While sweat is a healthy way for
the body to cool off, excessive sweating takes some calcium with it. If you are
very active (working out for an hour or more), be mindful of replacing not only
the fluids you lose through sweating, but also the vital minerals like
potassium, sodium, and calcium.
Calcium is an Enemy Too
While
there are clearly many roadblocks for calcium, the important mineral plays some
interference of its own. In fact, calcium blocks the absorption of lead in the
intestines. This is great news considering the dangerous implications of lead
poisoning. It also adds another reason for making sure that children, who are
especially at risk for lead toxicity, get enough calcium everyday (See also “ Kids Need Calcium”).
Other Calcium Challenges
While
absorbing calcium is clearly a challenge in itself, what happens if you can’t
eat some of the most calcium-rich foods? This is certainly the case for
individuals who are lactose intolerant or those who avoid dairy for personal
reason or as part of a strict vegetarian diet. For information on how to
conquer these challenges check out “ Calcium
Options for Lactose Intolerance & Dairy Avoidance”
References
National
Osteoporosis Foundation. What You Should
Know About Calcium. NOF.com. retrieved 6/11/08 LINK
[PRINTER FRIENDLY VERSION]
|