Google, the goofily named yet highly popular search engine,
has gotten into the news distribution business with Google News, an editor-free
compilation of approximately 4,000 news sources worldwide. And the service is
putting a new spin on the concept of Internet news delivery.
Google says the new service is “compiled solely by computer
algorithms without human intervention. Google employs no editors, managing
editors, or executive editors.” And the fact that the process produces some
unusual results is exactly what Google says it wants to achieve: “While the
sources of the news vary in perspective and editorial approach, their selection
for inclusion is done without regard to political viewpoint or ideology. While
this may lead to some occasionally unusual and contradictory groupings, it is
exactly this variety that makes Google News a valuable source of information on
the important issues of the day.
At least one techie so far thinks Google News will be a hit.
Leslie Walker, writing for TechNews.com calls Google News “more of a research
tool that piggybacks on news services” than a news service itself.
“Oh, Google News is buggy, all right, with stories
occasionally miscategorized and photographs appearing beside the wrong
headlines. What would you expect from the Internet’s first artificial
newscast?” she said. “My own experience watching Google’s digital newscast this
week suggests it will be a hit with news junkies, considering its diversity and
freshness.”
Potential problems for Google News include: how to fund the
thing; the prospect of irritating actual news originators over things like “deep linking,” and competition from
other “news aggregators like Yahoo and America Online.
According to Walker, Google refined its existing web search
technology to apply specifically to news and tossed the new service online to
let people sample it free while worrying about how to fund it
later on. Best guess is that funding the site will come from a mixture of
advertising, subscription fees and syndication sales. Currently the service is
offered free.
The deep linking issue may be bigger trouble. Walker reports
that the process sends readers directly to articles, bypassing the originating
site’s carefully constructed home pages. However “A Danish court in June held
that similar instances of deep linking were illegal in a case involving a
European news site,”she said.
Critical competitors are griping that the 100 percent hands
free approach can’t possibly produce “a meaningful picture of what is happing
in the world and people’s lives.” Walker said. But Google News responds that it
hasn’t made editors obsolete. Instead, it depends on the editorial judgment of
the news sites it “crawls” to understand what is important.
You can check out Google News at news.google.com.