Article from SCIP.online ()
August 21, 2002
Corporate earnings conference calls.
by Ed Curtin

Corporate earnings conference calls.

Ed Curtin, Senior Vice President, Fair Disclosure Financial Network,
ecurtin@fdfn.com


**********

Summary: Today's regulatory climate and investor sentiments have converged to transform earnings conference calls into an essential CI resources. Conference calls feature in-depth, probing Q&A on financial and operating performance, competitive trends, financial projections, and strategic opportunities and vulnerabilities.

**********


Under pressure from regulators, investors and the broader public, the corporate earnings conference call is fast emerging as one of the most useful new resources for CI professionals. The conference call has graduated from the pre-Regulation Fair Disclosure (Reg FD) era, when it was used, at least in part, to enforce a system of restricted, minimalist disclosure. Reg FD was passed by the SEC in October 2000, requiring public companies to broadly disclose information in a timely manner to all investors, not just selected favorites. (See detailed information at the SEC site http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/33-7881.htm.)

Today the conference call is a staple of corporate communications used by the overwhelming majority of public companies to cast an increasingly rich perspective on issues of greatest importance to CI professionals. Conference calls today feature in-depth, probing Q&A on financial and operating performance, competitive trends and financial projections, strategic opportunities and vulnerabilities, to name just a few of the common themes.

Conference calls are likely to continue growing in popularity, and the medium seems poised to take on greater informational value and analytical depth.   One reason for this is that greater transparency is increasingly seen as an important step toward restoring investor confidence.

Perhaps more importantly, recent SEC regulations such as Reg FD have placed fresh emphasis on full and equitable disclosure as a legal duty of public corporations. And since companies cannot disclose material information to the privileged few, it is in their interest to provide the richest possible disclosure in a public forum to minimize the risk of selective disclosure in the course of non-public dialogue with the investment community.


A bit of history

One could argue that before Reg FD, many companies did not make truly important corporate information (and management’s perspective on it) publicly available; rather, they reserved it for private conversations with Wall Street elites. What resulted was a system of tiered disclosure:

  • Level 1: Bare-minimum, sanitized, mostly-factual information (essentially, the company’s “party-line”) was placed in press releases
  • Level 2: Conference calls generally restricted to institutional investors and analysts, and provided more detail, more candor, less obfuscation.
  • Level 3: granted access to the select few analysts and investors. This is where these companies engaged their preferred audiences in private discussions of information that really mattered – concrete earnings and revenue projections, trends in particular line items in balance sheets and income statements, upcoming developments.

Under this tiered and arguably dysfunctional system, competitive intelligence sometimes took on unethical forms. Investor relations and sales executives would pose as investors or analysts to access the conference calls of their competitors. Some of these impostors would use the opportunity to challenge, confuse or embarrass the presenting companies by airing scathing and/or false information.


Earnings conference calls today

Today’s regulatory climate and investor sentiments have converged to transform earnings conference calls into an essential competitive intelligence resource.

In the 2001 survey of the National Investor Relations Institute (NIRI), 92 % of responding investor relations officers said they held quarterly conference calls, up from 88 % in 2000 and 80 percent in 1996. Almost all of the respondents in 2001 said they also provide a live web cast of the calls.  79 % said that they archive an audio copy of the call on their web sites (up from 63%) -- in most cases (88 %), for at least six days. A large majority of companies (79 %) provide earnings guidance, and conference calls are by far the preferred method for conveying this information.

The average number of participants in quarterly conference calls is rising steadily.  The NIRI survey cited the impact of Reg FD and the convenience of the medium as drivers of its growing popularity.  As the size of the audience on conference calls increases, so does its importance, providing further encouragement to companies to treat their quarterly conference calls as seminal disclosure events.
 

Information overload  

However, even with the growing importance of the conference call as a disclosure and guidance medium, information overload is the major impediment to using this medium as a competitive intelligence resource.  The volume and complexity of material corporate information is increasing dramatically, as new regulations mandate greater transparency and broader dissemination.  And the limitations of the conference call’s audio format only complicate this challenge: you cannot skim an audio conference call or perform an automated search for the most relevant content.


This is one of the challenges Fair Disclosure Financial Network (FDfn) was founded to address. We help streamline the intelligence/analytical process by converting audio conference calls into searchable verbatim transcripts – within minutes of real-time.  FDfn customers can search transcripts not only one by one, but also across industry groups and market indices.


Background:

Ed Curtin is Senior Vice President of Fair Disclosure Financial Network (
www.fdfn.com ). Ed joined FDfn in January 2002, as SVP for Corporate Business Development. He most recently worked for Thomson Financial Investor Relations (TFIR) as EVP for Business Operations was responsible for the strategic integration of four IR consulting and data information companies with 300 employees. After the integration, he became EVP Strategic Business Development with responsibility for global sales, marketing, alliances, acquisitions, and overall strategy.

FDfn is the world’s largest transcriber, webcaster and distributor of corporate earnings conference calls. Every quarter, the company webcasts and transcribes more than 4,000 calls. FDfn’s proprietary AnalystCall service converts audio-format conference calls into streaming text – minutes after the start of the call – and into searchable transcripts, soon after the end of the conference. This unique service streamlines the analytical process, offering corporations, investors and analysts significantly greater flexibility and control.

Copyright 2002 Society of Competitive Intelligence Professionals

SCIP.online, volume 1 number 14, August 22, 2002


Published by Society Competitive Intelligence Professionals
Copyright © 2009 Society of Competitive Intelligence Professionals. All rights reserved.
Powered by IMN