Article from The Sugarcrest Report ()
May 1, 2001
Advertising in a Buyers' Market
A Quick Review of Options and Costs
by David Goehl

With the Internet shakeout in full force, it's time to revisit and compare the costs of advertising online and in traditional media. Here's a quick rundown:

Online Advertising

Banner Ads: Banner ads, which are now used more often to create a recognizable brand than to prompt a specific action, range from $5 to $50 per 1,000 viewers, depending on how targeted the ad and the site on which it appears. The median rate is currently $25 per 1,000 viewers. Note, however, that these figures represent rate-card prices, the published rates Web sites say they're charging advertising customers. In a buyers' market like the one we have now, Web sites, like other media, often sell ads for less than a rate card shows. Also, note that there is a growing trend among advertisers to pay for Web ads on a per action basis (e.g. every time a viewer clicks on an ad or purchases a service or product; also known as "CPA"--Cost Per Action), rather than on a per impression basis (e.g. every time a viewer visits a site with the ad; also known as "CPM"--Cost Per 1,000 Impressions). Experts predict that Web advertising will eventually be split between impression and action based deals.

Rich Media: With the growth of high speed Internet connections, rich media ads that use animation, sound and streaming video are becoming more popular. The ads, which usually appear in pop-up windows, run between $40 and $50 per 1,000 ads that appear, depending on the quality and demographic of the site's audience. While the click-through rate for these ads (approximately 6%) generally outpaces rates for banner ads (.5%) and traditional direct mail (1% to 3%), many experts attribute this to experimentation and expect the rate to decline once the novelty wears off.

E-mail Ads/Newsletters: The majority of marketers (roughly 61%) use e-mail to retain customers. However, e-mail is also an efficient way to acquire new customers as it costs only a third as much as direct mail. Also, note that creative costs are roughly $1,000 for an e-mail ad campaign versus $20,000 for traditional direct mail. An e-mail in the form of an advertisement ranges from $100 to $200 per 1,000 e-mail addresses targeted, depending on the quality and demographic of the list of addresses. Content sponsored by an advertiser in a newsletter format ranges from $15 to $25 per 1,000 e-mail addresses targeted, depending on the cost to create and develop the e-mail. Jupiter Media Metrix Inc., a New York Internet-research firm, expects e-mail to be a $7.3 billion market by 2005, up from $164 million in 1999.

Sponsorships: Experts are in disagreement about the efficacy of advertisers linking their brands to areas of content on a Web site. Some highlight the opportunity to work closely with the Web publisher to customize a portion of the site. Others argue that sponsored areas invite skepticism about objectivity. A sponsorship per 1,000 viewers ranges from $30 to $75, depending on the exclusivity of the sponsorship. The more exclusive, the higher the cost.

Traditional Advertising

Local TV: A 30-second television commercial on a local station in a top 10 market ranges from $4,000, generally during a movie, to $45,000 for time on one of the highest-rated shows.

Network TV: A 30-second spot in prime time ranges from $80,000 to $600,000, depending on how high a show is rated and the show's genre. The average is $120,000 to $140,000.

Cable TV: A 30-second spot in prime time runs between $5,000 and $8,000, depending on the network.

Radio: Commercials range from $200 to $1,000 for a 60-second spot, depending on criteria such as the time of day and the program's ratings.

Newspapers: A full-page ad in the top 10 markets runs an estimated $120 per 1,000 circulation.

Magazines: Ads in regional editions of national magazines cost an average of about $50 per 1,000 circulation. The average cost of an ad in a local magazine is about $120 per 1,000 circulation.

Direct Mail: The most common forms of direct mail include messages in letter-sized envelopes, which cost $15 to $20 per 1,000 delivered, and single-sheet newspaper inserts like fliers, which cost between $25 and $40 per 1,000 circulation.

Billboards: To place several short-term ads for one to three months on a 14x48 sign along the freeway ranges from $5,000 to $25,000 in top 10 markets.

Sources: Wall Street Journal; Initiative Media North America, a division of Interpublic Group; and Carat Interactive, Inc.

Published by Sugarcrest Development Group, Inc.
Copyright © 2009 Sugarcrest Development Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
Powered by IMN