Article from Out of the Blue: PR Measurement News ()
September 22, 2009
Hot Dog! Reverence and Ridicule on a Bun
Strong Feelings for Lowbrow Food
www.blue-marble.com
by Jerry Brown

Hot Dogs

Forget those snooty folks who wouldn't stoop to letting a hot dog pass their lips. I'll take mine with mustard, sauerkraut or chili, thank you. The mustard and sauerkraut can go on by themselves or together. But the chili has to be all alone. And it has to be thick enough to stay put and not turn the bun soggy.

If you're like me, you have very definite ideas about what should -- and shouldn't -- go on a hot dog. For a food with such a lowbrow reputation, the care that goes into cooking and dressing them is truly impressive. They represent reverence and ridicule on a bun.

Ketchup or mustard seems one of the big dividing lines. Most people I know want one or the other, but not both. Relish is another divider. Personally, I think relish is best left on the grocer's shelf. Or maybe it could be used as paint pigment. But it should never ever make it's way onto any hot dog I'm going to eat.

I found a poll that showed about an even number of mustard users and misguided souls who put ketchup on their hot dogs. Relish, onions and cheese also are popular choices. But mayonnaise and Miracle Whip? On a hot dog? There's no accounting for some people's taste.

There's only one way to cook a hot dog: grilled over an open fire, the darker the better. My favorite recipe for boiling hot dogs is one I found on a Web site called Itsy's Hot Dog Kitchen: "Take two hot dogs. Place in 1/2qt pot. Bring to a boil for 10 min. Remove hot dogs and discard. Throw away water. Order out." Itsy? What kind of name is that?

The bun should be big enough to give you something to hold onto, but not big enough that you ever have more bread than meat in your mouth. If you remember the bun after you're done eating, you had the wrong one.

Why do they call them hot dogs?

It's easy to make fun of hot dogs. We've all heard the vague innuendo about the horrible things that go into them. Has anyone seen Fido lately? And we've all heard the claims that they'll give you cancer, clog your arteries or lower your social standing. But they taste so good.

With all the strong feelings generated by hot dogs, it was only a matter of time before the companies that make them found themselves participating in Facebook, Twitter and the other social media conversations to convince the rest of us to eat more of them. Or at least to buy our dogs from them.

For example, Ball Park Franks, Nathan's Famous and Oscar Mayer have taken the competitive fray over hot dogs to Facebook, Twitter, MySpace and the blogosphere. Ball Park and Nathan's Famous dogs seem to be dabbling in the social media arena more seriously than Oscar Mayer, as the results in the charts show.1

Voice Share

Ball Park has 13 percent of the hot dog "share of voice" in social media venues and Nathan's Famous is close behind with 11 percent. Kudos to the PR team for Ball Park or Nathan's for taking the conversation online.

Tone

The positive-versus-negative tone of the comments is even more impressive -- 25 to 1 for Ball Park and 24 to 1 for Nathan's. We always look to outweigh our negatively rated coverage with positive impressions about a brand. But consumers are noticing that some of those comments appear to have been placed and paid for by the companies. So, it's not a measure of unbiased opinions.

Velocity

And the real question is whether all this effort is really doing any good. That's not so clear. For example, the Ball Park and Nathan's arrows on the velocity graph -- a measure of how far and fast their social media comments traveled in a given time -- look pretty impressive until you understand what they show.

Over a four-month period Ball Park generated more than 500 comments and Nathan's more than 400 comments in the social media. And the total number of people who saw them? Under 5,000, which is smaller than the circulation of some neighborhood weekly newspapers.

What was the cost in time and dollars of getting those messages posted? And did any sales result from reaching those people who cared to converse about hot dogs? Many brands are currently evaluating the time, energy and money involved in using social media as a PR tactic. I'm not sure the hot dog makers have found their voice yet on Facebook and Twitter.


1Facebook, MySpace, Twitter and blogs. May 15-Sept. 15, 2009


ABOUT THE AUTHOR Jerry Brown committed journalism for 20 years, but received a full pardon. He's been practicing public relations for more than 25 years and plans to keep practicing until he gets it right -- which he hopes takes a long time because he likes what he does. He specializes in strategy and message development, media relations and media training and writing (news releases, annual report, collateral, etc.). He also writes the Monday Morning Media Minute, a free weekly media tip distributed by e-mail. You can reach him at jerry@pr-impact.com / 303-781-8787.



Published by Blue Marble Enterprises, Inc.
Copyright © 2009 Blue Marble Enterprises, Inc.. All rights reserved.

What is this? This is an e-mail newsletter to inform you of ideas, products, services and trends in PR measurement. The intent of this newsletter is to inform or provoke thought in a humorous way.

Why did you get it? Out of the Blue news is intended to be for interested professionals in the business of public relations. You received this message because you have asked to be on the Blue Marble Enterprises Newsletter distribution list, requested PR measurement service samples or you belong to a public relations organization or corporate PR department that published your email address. Please share it with anyone you think might be interested. If you would like to see a topic addressed by Out of the Blue, send your request to us at outoftheblue@blue-marble.com. To be removed from the distribution list, use the subscription box in the left frame of the newsletter.

Privacy statement: We will not share your name or contact information with anyone for any reason without your explicit approval in advance.

Powered by IMN